Using Cognitive Psychology to Build Self-Belief: Insights from Nick McDonald

In Episode 9 of the Leadership and Wellbeing podcast, Hayden Fricke had the privilege of speaking with Nick McDonald, CEO of Prestige Inhome Care, about his journey of using cognitive psychology to develop self-belief and transform his leadership style. With over 25 years of experience leading a team of 700, Nick’s story is an inspiring testament to the power of mindset, resilience, and growth.

Overcoming Self-Doubt

Despite his success, Nick initially struggled with self-doubt, particularly regarding his capabilities as a leader. His background in nursing led him to question his worthiness in leading a multi-million-dollar business. This lack of self-efficacy—the belief in one’s ability to succeed at a specific task—posed significant challenges. Nick’s journey underscores the distinction between self-worth, self-confidence, and self-efficacy, highlighting the importance of addressing limiting beliefs.

The Role of Cognitive Psychology

Nick’s transformation was guided by the principles of cognitive psychology. Leveraging frameworks such as Albert Ellis’ Rational Emotive Therapy (RET), Nick learned to identify and challenge unhelpful thoughts. RET posits that emotions are shaped by our beliefs about events rather than the events themselves. By reframing negative self-talk, Nick reduced anxiety and built a healthier mindset.

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) also played a crucial role, teaching Nick to acknowledge and let go of unhelpful thoughts without judgment. These tools enabled him to shift focus from self-doubt to actionable growth, fostering a more positive outlook.

Balancing Professional and Personal Life

At a pivotal point in his life, Nick realized the need to balance his professional responsibilities with his personal wellbeing. He implemented strategies to set boundaries, such as turning off his phone during family time and engaging in activities that brought him joy. These efforts aligned with the Effort Recovery Model by Meijman and Mulder, which emphasizes the importance of psychological detachment from work to maintain emotional and physical energy.

Lessons from Episode 10: Self-Belief as a Superpower

In Episode 10, we reflected on Nick’s journey and explored the broader implications of self-belief for leaders. Using frameworks like the ABC Model (Activating Event, Belief, Consequence), leaders can better understand how their thoughts impact their emotions and actions. Additionally, Jonathan Haidt’s “Elephant and Rider” metaphor provides insights into managing the interplay between emotional and rational decision-making.

Nick also embraced the GROW model (Goals, Reality, Options, Will), which empowered him to coach his team effectively. By setting clear goals and exploring actionable solutions, Nick cultivated a high-performing team rooted in trust and psychological safety.

Key Takeaways for Leaders

  1. Challenge Limiting Beliefs: Use cognitive psychology tools to identify and reframe unhelpful thoughts.
  2. Foster Self-Belief: Build confidence through small, deliberate actions that align with your values and goals.
  3. Balance Work and Life: Prioritize activities that promote recovery and detachment from work-related stress.
  4. Develop Your Team: Apply coaching frameworks like GROW to empower and support your team’s growth.
  5. Embrace Vulnerability: Acknowledge challenges openly to build trust and authenticity within your organization.

Why This Matters

Nick’s journey offers valuable lessons for leaders at all levels. Whether you’re navigating self-doubt or striving to enhance team performance, these insights provide practical strategies for personal and professional growth. Leaders can draw on these lessons to foster resilience, drive engagement, and lead with purpose.

Take the Next Step

For more inspiration, tune in to Episodes 9 and 10 of the Leadership and Wellbeing podcast. Discover how cognitive psychology can transform your mindset and unlock your potential as a leader.


Connect with Hayden: